Lessons from Plagues & Poxes
The invisible armies that have swayed the fate of nations
Imagine a world where a mosquito's bite could determine the outcome of a war, where a silent microbe could depopulate continents, and where the success of empires hinged as much on immunity as on military might. This is the hidden history of humanity—a story told not through treaties and battles alone, but through the pandemics that have alternately crippled and transformed civilizations.
In his groundbreaking 1987 work, Plagues & Poxes: The Rise and Fall of Epidemic Disease, medical historian Alfred Jay Bollet masterfully unravels this complex relationship between human history and infectious disease. He demonstrates how epidemics have been accidental travelers on the pathways of human commerce and migration, and sometimes even deliberate weapons of war. This article explores Bollet's compelling thesis that to understand history, we must first understand the diseases that have shaped it.
Bollet's work compellingly argues that epidemic diseases have been powerful historical forces, often operating as unseen architects of human destiny. His analysis spans centuries, revealing how diseases have altered military campaigns, decimated indigenous populations, and spurred scientific revolutions.
A central theme in Plagues & Poxes is the concept of the "exchange of diseases" following major human migrations and explorations. Bollet details how the Columbian Exchange—the transference of people, plants, animals, and cultures between the Old and New Worlds—also became a devastating biological exchange .
Smallpox and measles, brought to the Americas by European explorers, swept through populations with no prior exposure or immunity, causing mortality rates that arguably exceeded those from any military conflict.
Similarly, the importation of enslaved people from Africa brought new diseases like malaria and yellow fever to the Western hemisphere, while syphilis appears to have been introduced to Europe from the Americas . This microbial shuffling forever altered the demographic landscapes of continents.
Another critical concept Bollet explores is how human societal evolution itself created new disease patterns. The development of agriculture and, later, dense urban centers provided the perfect conditions for what he terms "crowd diseases" .
In small, isolated communities, a highly virulent disease would either kill its hosts or confer immunity, then burn out for lack of new susceptible individuals. But in the ever-larger cities of Europe and North America, diseases like polio could persist because there were always enough non-immune people to keep the chain of infection alive.
Our greatest human achievements—cities, trade networks, and empires—unwittingly became the perfect breeding grounds for microscopic invaders.
One of the most fascinating aspects of Bollet's methodology is his application of modern medical knowledge to reinterpret historical events. He acts as a medical detective, examining historical accounts of symptoms, suffering, and death through a contemporary clinical lens to deduce what diseases people in the past were actually describing.
For example, the term "spring fever," as used by American colonists, did not originally refer to romantic yearning. Bollet traces it back to the scurvy-induced lassitude that set in after a winter without fresh fruits or vegetables . This nutritional deficiency, caused by a lack of vitamin C, would manifest as profound fatigue and weakness as winter stores ran out, a symptom that was misattributed to the changing seasons.
Similarly, Bollet delves into the historical confusion between different diseases. He points out that venereal urethritis was recognized for millennia before syphilis emerged as a distinct, major epidemic in Europe, and that ancient descriptions often lacked critical details—like whether a urethral discharge was painful—that would allow for a clear modern diagnosis . This kind of critical analysis helps separate historical fact from diagnostic assumption.
Test your knowledge of historical diseases and their modern interpretations:
Historical Term: "The English Disease"
| Historical Term/Event | Proposed Modern Diagnosis | Key Evidence |
|---|---|---|
| "Spring Fever" (American Colonies) | Scurvy (Vitamin C Deficiency) | Seasonal pattern after winter, symptoms of weakness and lethargy |
| The "Great Pox" (1490s Europe) | Syphilis | Distinctive symptoms and timing of its widespread appearance 5 |
| "The English Disease" | Rickets (Vitamin D Deficiency) | Prevalence in industrialized cities with smog, affecting bone development 5 |
| "The Black Death" (14th Century) | Bubonic Plague (Yersinia pestis) | Descriptions of characteristic buboes (swollen lymph nodes) and rapid spread 8 |
Bollet dedicates significant attention to bubonic plague, which he describes as "the prototype of pandemic disasters" 5 . The Black Death of the 14th century, caused by the bacterium Yersinia pestis, killed an estimated one-third of Europe's population 8 .
Bollet explains the complex ecology of the disease—a cycle involving wild rodents and their fleas that occasionally spills over into humans 8 .
When an outbreak kills off the rodent population, infected fleas abandon the dead hosts and seek new sources of blood, turning to humans. This transmission dynamic, understood only centuries later, explains the terrifying and seemingly inexplicable surges of the disease that shaped medieval society, culture, and even the pace of technological innovation by creating labor shortages.
Another compelling case study is syphilis. Bollet explores the debate surrounding its sudden and devastating appearance in Europe at the end of the 15th century. The "Columbian theory" suggests that the disease was brought back to Europe by Columbus's crew from the Americas, while competing theories propose it existed in the Old World earlier but was not distinguished from other diseases .
Bollet's historical medical perspective allows him to weigh the evidence, such as the timing of the first recorded epidemics and the descriptions of its severity, which suggest it was a new and terrifying phenomenon for Europeans. This investigation highlights a recurring theme in the book: how the movement of people is so often the vehicle for the movement of disease.
Beyond infectious diseases, Bollet breaks new ground by exploring the history of epidemic deficiency diseases. He notes the conceptual revolution required for this understanding: for centuries, disease was seen as the presence of something abnormal—a pathogen, a poison, a malign influence. The idea that sickness could be caused by the absence of something—a specific nutrient—was a radical departure .
He presents the intriguing argument that "the first epidemic disease in human history probably was iron deficiency anemia," which would have emerged when humans shifted from a hunter-gatherer diet rich in meat to an agricultural diet reliant on grains, which are poor sources of bioavailable iron .
This section also covers diseases like beriberi, which became epidemic with the introduction of modern rice milling that stripped the vitamin B1-rich husk from the grain, and pellagra, which ravaged populations whose diet had become centered on corn 5 . These stories powerfully illustrate that human technological "advances" can have unexpected and devastating health consequences.
| Disease | Deficient Nutrient | Historical Population Affected |
|---|---|---|
| Scurvy | Vitamin C | Sailors, soldiers, populations in winter |
| Beriberi | Vitamin B1 (Thiamine) | Populations dependent on milled rice |
| Pellagra | Niacin (Vitamin B3) | Populations dependent on corn/maize 5 |
| Rickets | Vitamin D | Urban poor, children in smoggy cities 5 |
A particularly prescient chapter in Bollet's analysis, which became even more relevant in the updated 2004 edition, is the history of biological warfare. He makes it clear that biological warfare is not a modern invention .
There have been attempts to intentionally spread disease for military advantage throughout history, from the contamination of wells with corpses to the infamous distribution of smallpox-infected blankets to Native American populations during the French and Indian War . Bollet's historical tracing of this dark practice provides crucial context for understanding its modern incarnation, where advanced technology has raised the stakes, making diseases like anthrax potential weapons of terrorism .
Alfred Jay Bollet's Plagues & Poxes is more than a history of medicine; it is a history of humanity told through our most persistent and deadly companions—the diseases we have fought, fled, and sometimes inadvertently fostered. His work leaves us with a profound understanding that the rise and fall of epidemic disease is inextricably linked to the arc of human history itself.
From the bubonic plague that reshaped medieval Europe to the nutritional deficiencies that emerged from our dietary choices, the story of disease is a story of our own making. It is a narrative of unintended consequences, of scientific triumphs, and of a perpetual dance between humankind and the microscopic world.
As we face new and re-emerging infectious diseases in our own globally connected world, the lessons from Bollet's work are more vital than ever. They teach us humility, resilience, and the timeless truth that our health, our history, and our future are deeply intertwined.
References will be added here manually in the future.